Causal Inference with Synthetic Control Methods by Density Matching under Implicit Endogeneitiy

Synthetic control methods (SCMs) have become a crucial tool for causal inference in comparative case studies. The fundamental idea of SCMs is to estimate counterfactual outcomes for a treated unit by using a weighted sum of observed outcomes from untreated units. The accuracy of the synthetic control (SC) is critical for estimating the causal effect, and therefore, the estimation of SC weights has been the focus of much research. In this paper, we first point out that existing SCMs suffer from an implicit endogeneity problem, which is the correlation between the outcomes of untreated units and the error term of the synthetic control, and yields a bias in the causal effect estimator. We then propose a novel SCM based on density matching, assuming that the density of outcomes of the treated unit can be approximated by a weighted average of the joint density of untreated units (i.e., a mixture model). Based on this assumption, we estimate SC weights by matching moments of treated outcomes and the weighted sum of moments of untreated outcomes. Our proposed method has three advantages over existing methods. First, our estimator is asymptotically unbiased under the assumption of the mixture model. Second, due to the asymptotic unbiasedness, we can reduce the mean squared error for counterfactual prediction. Third, our method generates full densities of the treatment effect, not only expected values, which broadens the applicability of SCMs. We provide experimental results to demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed method.