Any-Order GPT as Masked Diffusion Model: Decoupling Formulation and Architecture

Efficiently scaling Large Language Models (LLMs) necessitates exploring alternatives to dominant autoregressive (AR) methods, with Masked Diffusion Models (MDMs) emerging as candidates. However, comparing AR (typically decoder-only) and MDM (often encoder-only) paradigms is confounded by differing architectures, obscuring true algorithmic and efficiency trade-offs. This research decouples these factors by evaluating MDMs within a decoder-only framework to: (1) Equitably compare MDM (as Any-Order AR) and standard AR paradigms through discrepancies on orders. (2) Investigate MDM architectural impacts on computational efficiency. We show decoder-only MDMs, despite a larger modeling space, can achieve significant inference speedups ($\sim25\times$) and comparable perplexity with techniques like temperature annealing, offering a path to reduced inference compute. This work provides insights for developing more computationally efficient foundation models by disentangling core modeling choices from architectural influences. Code is available at \url{https://github.com/scxue/AO-GPT-MDM}.