Faithful Relational Reasoning with Region-based Embeddings: Expressivity of Convex Coordinate-wise Models

Embedding methods are among the most efficient approaches for learning to reason about relational knowledge. In this paper, we focus on the framework of region-based embeddings, where relations are encoded as geometric regions. The spatial arrangement of these regions allows such models to capture symbolic rules, enabling them to simulate some forms of symbolic reasoning. A crucial consideration is how the regions are parameterized, as this affects which rule bases can be captured. Most methods use convex regions which are defined in terms of coordinate-wise comparisons. This makes them highly efficient, but the implications of this choice have thus far remained unclear. We present a series of results that shed light on this issue, showing that convex coordinate-wise models indeed have important limitations, while at the same time showing that there is still room for pushing the expressivity of existing coordinate-wise models.