Timezone: »
We build four new test sets for the Stanford Question Answering Dataset (SQuAD) and evaluate the ability of question-answering systems to generalize to new data. Our first test set is from the original Wikipedia domain and measures the extent to which existing systems overfit the original test set. Despite several years of heavy test set re-use, we find no evidence of adaptive overfitting. The remaining three test sets are constructed from New York Times articles, Reddit posts, and Amazon product reviews and measure robustness to natural distribution shifts. Across a broad range of models, we observe average performance drops of 3.8, 14.0, and 17.4 F1 points, respectively. In contrast, a strong human baseline matches or exceeds the performance of SQuAD models on the original domain and exhibits little to no drop in new domains. Taken together, our results confirm the surprising resilience of the holdout method and emphasize the need to move towards evaluation metrics that incorporate robustness to natural distribution shifts.
Author Information
John Miller (University of California, Berkeley)
Karl Krauth (UC Berkeley)
Benjamin Recht (Berkeley)
Benjamin Recht is an Associate Professor in the Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Sciences at the University of California, Berkeley. Ben's research group studies the theory and practice of optimization algorithms with a focus on applications in machine learning, data analysis, and controls. Ben is the recipient of a Presidential Early Career Awards for Scientists and Engineers, an Alfred P. Sloan Research Fellowship, the 2012 SIAM/MOS Lagrange Prize in Continuous Optimization, the 2014 Jamon Prize, the 2015 William O. Baker Award for Initiatives in Research, and the 2017 NIPS Test of Time Award.
Ludwig Schmidt (University of California, Berkeley)
More from the Same Authors
-
2021 Poster: Quantifying Availability and Discovery in Recommender Systems via Stochastic Reachability »
Mihaela Curmei · Sarah Dean · Benjamin Recht -
2021 Spotlight: Quantifying Availability and Discovery in Recommender Systems via Stochastic Reachability »
Mihaela Curmei · Sarah Dean · Benjamin Recht -
2021 Poster: Outside the Echo Chamber: Optimizing the Performative Risk »
John Miller · Juan Perdomo · Tijana Zrnic -
2021 Poster: Accuracy on the Line: on the Strong Correlation Between Out-of-Distribution and In-Distribution Generalization »
John Miller · Rohan Taori · Aditi Raghunathan · Shiori Sagawa · Pang Wei Koh · Vaishaal Shankar · Percy Liang · Yair Carmon · Ludwig Schmidt -
2021 Poster: Representation Matters: Assessing the Importance of Subgroup Allocations in Training Data »
Esther Rolf · Theodora Worledge · Benjamin Recht · Michael Jordan -
2021 Spotlight: Accuracy on the Line: on the Strong Correlation Between Out-of-Distribution and In-Distribution Generalization »
John Miller · Rohan Taori · Aditi Raghunathan · Shiori Sagawa · Pang Wei Koh · Vaishaal Shankar · Percy Liang · Yair Carmon · Ludwig Schmidt -
2021 Spotlight: Outside the Echo Chamber: Optimizing the Performative Risk »
John Miller · Juan Perdomo · Tijana Zrnic -
2021 Spotlight: Representation Matters: Assessing the Importance of Subgroup Allocations in Training Data »
Esther Rolf · Theodora Worledge · Benjamin Recht · Michael Jordan -
2020 Poster: Neural Kernels Without Tangents »
Vaishaal Shankar · Alex Fang · Wenshuo Guo · Sara Fridovich-Keil · Jonathan Ragan-Kelley · Ludwig Schmidt · Benjamin Recht -
2020 Poster: Evaluating Machine Accuracy on ImageNet »
Vaishaal Shankar · Rebecca Roelofs · Horia Mania · Alex Fang · Benjamin Recht · Ludwig Schmidt -
2020 Poster: Strategic Classification is Causal Modeling in Disguise »
John Miller · Smitha Milli · Moritz Hardt -
2020 Poster: Test-Time Training with Self-Supervision for Generalization under Distribution Shifts »
Yu Sun · Xiaolong Wang · Zhuang Liu · John Miller · Alexei Efros · Moritz Hardt -
2019 Workshop: Identifying and Understanding Deep Learning Phenomena »
Hanie Sedghi · Samy Bengio · Kenji Hata · Aleksander Madry · Ari Morcos · Behnam Neyshabur · Maithra Raghu · Ali Rahimi · Ludwig Schmidt · Ying Xiao -
2019 Poster: Do ImageNet Classifiers Generalize to ImageNet? »
Benjamin Recht · Rebecca Roelofs · Ludwig Schmidt · Vaishaal Shankar -
2019 Oral: Do ImageNet Classifiers Generalize to ImageNet? »
Benjamin Recht · Rebecca Roelofs · Ludwig Schmidt · Vaishaal Shankar -
2018 Poster: Least-Squares Temporal Difference Learning for the Linear Quadratic Regulator »
Stephen Tu · Benjamin Recht -
2018 Oral: Least-Squares Temporal Difference Learning for the Linear Quadratic Regulator »
Stephen Tu · Benjamin Recht -
2018 Tutorial: Optimization Perspectives on Learning to Control »
Benjamin Recht -
2017 Poster: Breaking Locality Accelerates Block Gauss-Seidel »
Stephen Tu · Shivaram Venkataraman · Ashia Wilson · Alex Gittens · Michael Jordan · Benjamin Recht -
2017 Talk: Breaking Locality Accelerates Block Gauss-Seidel »
Stephen Tu · Shivaram Venkataraman · Ashia Wilson · Alex Gittens · Michael Jordan · Benjamin Recht