Timezone: »
We present a novel technique for tailoring Bayesian quadrature (BQ) to model selection. The state-of-the-art for comparing the evidence of multiple models relies on Monte Carlo methods, which converge slowly and are unreliable for computationally expensive models. Although previous research has shown that BQ offers sample efficiency superior to Monte Carlo in computing the evidence of an individual model, applying BQ directly to model comparison may waste computation producing an overly-accurate estimate for the evidence of a clearly poor model. We propose an automated and efficient algorithm for computing the most-relevant quantity for model selection: the posterior model probability. Our technique maximizes the mutual information between this quantity and observations of the models' likelihoods, yielding efficient sample acquisition across disparate model spaces when likelihood observations are limited. Our method produces more-accurate posterior estimates using fewer likelihood evaluations than standard Bayesian quadrature and Monte Carlo estimators, as we demonstrate on synthetic and real-world examples.
Author Information
Henry Chai (Washington University in St. Louis)
Jean-Francois Ton (University of Oxford)
Michael A Osborne (U Oxford)
Roman Garnett (Washington University in St. Louis)
Related Events (a corresponding poster, oral, or spotlight)
-
2019 Oral: Automated Model Selection with Bayesian Quadrature »
Wed. Jun 12th 07:10 -- 07:15 PM Room Room 101
More from the Same Authors
-
2021 : Attacking Graph Classification via Bayesian Optimisation »
Xingchen Wan · Henry Kenlay · Binxin Ru · Arno Blaas · Michael A Osborne · Xiaowen Dong -
2021 : Revisiting Design Choices in Offline Model Based Reinforcement Learning »
Cong Lu · Philip Ball · Jack Parker-Holder · Michael A Osborne · Stephen Roberts -
2022 : Challenges and Opportunities in Offline Reinforcement Learning from Visual Observations »
Cong Lu · Philip Ball · Tim G. J Rudner · Jack Parker-Holder · Michael A Osborne · Yee-Whye Teh -
2022 Poster: Robust Multi-Objective Bayesian Optimization Under Input Noise »
Samuel Daulton · Sait Cakmak · Maximilian Balandat · Michael A Osborne · Enlu Zhou · Eytan Bakshy -
2022 Spotlight: Robust Multi-Objective Bayesian Optimization Under Input Noise »
Samuel Daulton · Sait Cakmak · Maximilian Balandat · Michael A Osborne · Enlu Zhou · Eytan Bakshy -
2021 Workshop: Challenges in Deploying and monitoring Machine Learning Systems »
Alessandra Tosi · Nathan Korda · Michael A Osborne · Stephen Roberts · Andrei Paleyes · Fariba Yousefi -
2021 Poster: Nonmyopic Multifidelity Acitve Search »
Quan Nguyen · Arghavan Modiri · Roman Garnett -
2021 Spotlight: Nonmyopic Multifidelity Acitve Search »
Quan Nguyen · Arghavan Modiri · Roman Garnett -
2021 Poster: Think Global and Act Local: Bayesian Optimisation over High-Dimensional Categorical and Mixed Search Spaces »
Xingchen Wan · Vu Nguyen · Huong Ha · Binxin Ru · Cong Lu · Michael A Osborne -
2021 Poster: Optimal Transport Kernels for Sequential and Parallel Neural Architecture Search »
Vu Nguyen · Tam Le · Makoto Yamada · Michael A Osborne -
2021 Spotlight: Think Global and Act Local: Bayesian Optimisation over High-Dimensional Categorical and Mixed Search Spaces »
Xingchen Wan · Vu Nguyen · Huong Ha · Binxin Ru · Cong Lu · Michael A Osborne -
2021 Spotlight: Optimal Transport Kernels for Sequential and Parallel Neural Architecture Search »
Vu Nguyen · Tam Le · Makoto Yamada · Michael A Osborne -
2020 Poster: BINOCULARS for efficient, nonmyopic sequential experimental design »
Shali Jiang · Henry Chai · Javier Gonzalez · Roman Garnett -
2020 Poster: MetaFun: Meta-Learning with Iterative Functional Updates »
Jin Xu · Jean-Francois Ton · Hyunjik Kim · Adam Kosiorek · Yee-Whye Teh -
2020 Poster: Knowing The What But Not The Where in Bayesian Optimization »
Vu Nguyen · Michael A Osborne -
2020 Poster: Bayesian Optimisation over Multiple Continuous and Categorical Inputs »
Binxin Ru · Ahsan Alvi · Vu Nguyen · Michael A Osborne · Stephen Roberts -
2019 Poster: On the Limitations of Representing Functions on Sets »
Edward Wagstaff · Fabian Fuchs · Martin Engelcke · Ingmar Posner · Michael A Osborne -
2019 Oral: On the Limitations of Representing Functions on Sets »
Edward Wagstaff · Fabian Fuchs · Martin Engelcke · Ingmar Posner · Michael A Osborne -
2019 Poster: AReS and MaRS - Adversarial and MMD-Minimizing Regression for SDEs »
Gabriele Abbati · Philippe Wenk · Michael A Osborne · Andreas Krause · Bernhard Schölkopf · Stefan Bauer -
2019 Poster: Asynchronous Batch Bayesian Optimisation with Improved Local Penalisation »
Ahsan Alvi · Binxin Ru · Jan-Peter Calliess · Stephen Roberts · Michael A Osborne -
2019 Oral: AReS and MaRS - Adversarial and MMD-Minimizing Regression for SDEs »
Gabriele Abbati · Philippe Wenk · Michael A Osborne · Andreas Krause · Bernhard Schölkopf · Stefan Bauer -
2019 Oral: Asynchronous Batch Bayesian Optimisation with Improved Local Penalisation »
Ahsan Alvi · Binxin Ru · Jan-Peter Calliess · Stephen Roberts · Michael A Osborne -
2019 Poster: Fingerprint Policy Optimisation for Robust Reinforcement Learning »
Supratik Paul · Michael A Osborne · Shimon Whiteson -
2019 Poster: Towards a Unified Analysis of Random Fourier Features »
Zhu Li · Jean-Francois Ton · Dino Oglic · Dino Sejdinovic -
2019 Oral: Fingerprint Policy Optimisation for Robust Reinforcement Learning »
Supratik Paul · Michael A Osborne · Shimon Whiteson -
2019 Oral: Towards a Unified Analysis of Random Fourier Features »
Zhu Li · Jean-Francois Ton · Dino Oglic · Dino Sejdinovic -
2018 Poster: Fast Information-theoretic Bayesian Optimisation »
Binxin Ru · Michael A Osborne · Mark Mcleod · Diego Granziol -
2018 Poster: Optimization, fast and slow: optimally switching between local and Bayesian optimization »
Mark McLeod · Stephen Roberts · Michael A Osborne -
2018 Oral: Optimization, fast and slow: optimally switching between local and Bayesian optimization »
Mark McLeod · Stephen Roberts · Michael A Osborne -
2018 Oral: Fast Information-theoretic Bayesian Optimisation »
Binxin Ru · Michael A Osborne · Mark Mcleod · Diego Granziol -
2017 Workshop: Automatic Machine Learning (AutoML 2017) »
Joaquin Vanschoren · Roman Garnett -
2017 Poster: Efficient Nonmyopic Active Search »
Shali Jiang · Luiz Gustavo Malkomes · Geoff Converse · Alyssa Shofner · Benjamin Moseley · Roman Garnett -
2017 Talk: Efficient Nonmyopic Active Search »
Shali Jiang · Luiz Gustavo Malkomes · Geoff Converse · Alyssa Shofner · Benjamin Moseley · Roman Garnett