Timezone: »
This workshop focuses on issues of reproducibility and replication of results in the Machine Learning community. Papers from the Machine Learning community are supposed to be a valuable asset. They can help to inform and inspire future research. They can be a useful educational tool for students. They can give guidance to applied researchers in industry. Perhaps most importantly, they can help us to answer the most fundamental questions about our existence - what does it mean to learn and what does it mean to be human? Reproducibility, while not always possible in science (consider the study of a transient astrological phenomenon like a passing comet), is a powerful criteria for improving the quality of research. A result which is reproducible is more likely to be robust and meaningful and rules out many types of experimenter error (either fraud or accidental).
There are many interesting open questions about how reproducibility issues intersect with the Machine Learning community:
* How can we tell if papers in the Machine Learning community are reproducible even in theory? If a paper is about recommending news sites before a particular election, and the results come from running the system online in production - it will be impossible to reproduce the published results because the state of the world is irreversibly changed from when the experiment was ran.
* What does it mean for a paper to be reproducible in theory but not in practice? For example, if a paper requires tens of thousands of GPUs to reproduce or a large closed-off dataset, then it can only be reproduced in reality by a few large labs.
* For papers which are reproducible both in theory and in practice - how can we ensure that papers published in ICML would actually be able to replicate if such an experiment were attempted?
* What does it mean for a paper to have successful or unsuccessful replications?
* Of the papers with attempted replications completed, how many have been published?
* What can be done to ensure that as many papers which are reproducible in theory fall into the last category?
* On the reproducibility issue, what can the Machine Learning community learn from other fields?
Our aim in the following workshop is to raise the profile of these questions in the community and to search for their answers. In doing so we aim for papers focusing on the following topics:
* Analysis of the current state of reproducibility in machine learning venues
* Tools to help increase reproducibility
* Evidence that reproducibility is important for science
* Connections between the reproducibility situation in Machine Learning and other fields
* Replications, both failed and successful, of influential papers in the Machine Learning literature.
Author Information
Rosemary Nan Ke (MILA, University of Montreal)
I am a PhD student at Mila, I am advised by Chris Pal and Yoshua Bengio. My research interest are efficient credit assignment, causal learning and model-based reinforcement learning. Here is my homepage https://nke001.github.io/
Anirudh Goyal (Université de Montréal)
Alex Lamb (Microsoft Research New York City)
Joelle Pineau (McGill University / Facebook)
Samy Bengio (Apple MLR)
Yoshua Bengio (Mila - Quebec AI Institute)
Yoshua Bengio is recognized as one of the world’s leading experts in artificial intelligence and a pioneer in deep learning. Since 1993, he has been a professor in the Department of Computer Science and Operational Research at the Université de Montréal. He is the founder and scientific director of Mila, the Quebec Institute of Artificial Intelligence, the world’s largest university-based research group in deep learning. He is a member of the NeurIPS board and co-founder and general chair for the ICLR conference, as well as program director of the CIFAR program on Learning in Machines and Brains and is Fellow of the same institution. In 2018, Yoshua Bengio ranked as the computer scientist with the most new citations, worldwide, thanks to his many publications. In 2019, he received the ACM A.M. Turing Award, “the Nobel Prize of Computing”, jointly with Geoffrey Hinton and Yann LeCun for conceptual and engineering breakthroughs that have made deep neural networks a critical component of computing. In 2020 he was nominated Fellow of the Royal Society of London.
More from the Same Authors
-
2021 : Variational Causal Networks: Approximate Bayesian Inference over Causal Structures »
Yashas Annadani · Jonas Rothfuss · Alexandre Lacoste · Nino Scherrer · Anirudh Goyal · Yoshua Bengio · Stefan Bauer -
2022 : Learning to induce causal structure »
Rosemary Nan Ke · Silvia Chiappa · Jane Wang · Jorg Bornschein · Anirudh Goyal · Melanie Rey · Matthew Botvinick · Theophane Weber · Michael Mozer · Danilo J. Rezende -
2022 : On the Generalization and Adaption Performance of Causal Models »
Nino Scherrer · Anirudh Goyal · Stefan Bauer · Yoshua Bengio · Rosemary Nan Ke -
2022 : P28: On the Generalization and Adaption Performance of Causal Models »
Rosemary Nan Ke -
2023 : Fostering Women's Leadership in the Realm of Emerging Trends and Technologies »
Joelle Pineau · Rihab Gorsane · Pascale FUNG -
2023 : Panel on Reasoning Capabilities of LLMs »
Guy Van den Broeck · Ishita Dasgupta · Subbarao Kambhampati · Jiajun Wu · Xi Victoria Lin · Samy Bengio · Beliz Gunel -
2023 : Joelle Pineau - A culture of open and reproducible research, in the era of large AI generative models »
Joelle Pineau -
2023 : Generalization on the Unseen, Logic Reasoning and Degree Curriculum »
Samy Bengio -
2023 Panel: The Societal Impacts of AI »
Sanmi Koyejo · Samy Bengio · Ashia Wilson · Kirikowhai Mikaere · Joelle Pineau -
2023 Poster: GFlowOut: Dropout with Generative Flow Networks »
Dianbo Liu · Moksh Jain · Bonaventure F. P. Dossou · Qianli Shen · Salem Lahlou · Anirudh Goyal · Nikolay Malkin · Chris Emezue · Dinghuai Zhang · Nadhir Hassen · Xu Ji · Kenji Kawaguchi · Yoshua Bengio -
2023 Poster: Discrete Key-Value Bottleneck »
Frederik Träuble · Anirudh Goyal · Nasim Rahaman · Michael Mozer · Kenji Kawaguchi · Yoshua Bengio · Bernhard Schölkopf -
2023 Poster: Generalization on the Unseen, Logic Reasoning and Degree Curriculum »
Emmanuel Abbe · Samy Bengio · Aryo Lotfi · Kevin Rizk -
2023 Oral: Generalization on the Unseen, Logic Reasoning and Degree Curriculum »
Emmanuel Abbe · Samy Bengio · Aryo Lotfi · Kevin Rizk -
2023 Poster: Test-time Adaptation with Slot-Centric Models »
Mihir Prabhudesai · Anirudh Goyal · Sujoy Paul · Sjoerd van Steenkiste · Mehdi S. M. Sajjadi · Gaurav Aggarwal · Thomas Kipf · Deepak Pathak · Katerina Fragkiadaki -
2023 Tutorial: Discovering Agent-Centric Latent States in Theory and in Practice »
John Langford · Alex Lamb -
2022 : Session 1: New Reasoning Problems and Modes of Reasoning »
Robert Ness · Rosemary Nan Ke · Armando Solar-Lezama -
2022 Poster: Retrieval-Augmented Reinforcement Learning »
Anirudh Goyal · Abe Friesen Friesen · Andrea Banino · Theophane Weber · Nan Rosemary Ke · Adrià Puigdomenech Badia · Arthur Guez · Mehdi Mirza · Peter Humphreys · Ksenia Konyushkova · Michal Valko · Simon Osindero · Timothy Lillicrap · Nicolas Heess · Charles Blundell -
2022 Spotlight: Retrieval-Augmented Reinforcement Learning »
Anirudh Goyal · Abe Friesen Friesen · Andrea Banino · Theophane Weber · Nan Rosemary Ke · Adrià Puigdomenech Badia · Arthur Guez · Mehdi Mirza · Peter Humphreys · Ksenia Konyushkova · Michal Valko · Simon Osindero · Timothy Lillicrap · Nicolas Heess · Charles Blundell -
2021 : Panel Discussion »
Rosemary Nan Ke · Danijar Hafner · Pieter Abbeel · Chelsea Finn · Chelsea Finn -
2021 : Invited Talk by Nan Rosemary Ke »
Rosemary Nan Ke -
2021 Workshop: ICML 2021 Workshop on Unsupervised Reinforcement Learning »
Feryal Behbahani · Joelle Pineau · Lerrel Pinto · Roberta Raileanu · Aravind Srinivas · Denis Yarats · Amy Zhang -
2021 Poster: On Disentangled Representations Learned from Correlated Data »
Frederik Träuble · Elliot Creager · Niki Kilbertus · Francesco Locatello · Andrea Dittadi · Anirudh Goyal · Bernhard Schölkopf · Stefan Bauer -
2021 Poster: Robust Representation Learning via Perceptual Similarity Metrics »
Saeid A Taghanaki · Kristy Choi · Amir Hosein Khasahmadi · Anirudh Goyal -
2021 Oral: On Disentangled Representations Learned from Correlated Data »
Frederik Träuble · Elliot Creager · Niki Kilbertus · Francesco Locatello · Andrea Dittadi · Anirudh Goyal · Bernhard Schölkopf · Stefan Bauer -
2021 Spotlight: Robust Representation Learning via Perceptual Similarity Metrics »
Saeid A Taghanaki · Kristy Choi · Amir Hosein Khasahmadi · Anirudh Goyal -
2021 Poster: OptiDICE: Offline Policy Optimization via Stationary Distribution Correction Estimation »
Jongmin Lee · Wonseok Jeon · Byung-Jun Lee · Joelle Pineau · Kee-Eung Kim -
2021 Spotlight: OptiDICE: Offline Policy Optimization via Stationary Distribution Correction Estimation »
Jongmin Lee · Wonseok Jeon · Byung-Jun Lee · Joelle Pineau · Kee-Eung Kim -
2020 Workshop: Inductive Biases, Invariances and Generalization in Reinforcement Learning »
Anirudh Goyal · Rosemary Nan Ke · Jane Wang · Stefan Bauer · Theophane Weber · Fabio Viola · Bernhard Schölkopf · Stefan Bauer -
2020 Workshop: MLRetrospectives: A Venue for Self-Reflection in ML Research »
Jessica Forde · Jesse Dodge · Mayoore Jaiswal · Rosanne Liu · Ryan Lowe · Rosanne Liu · Joelle Pineau · Yoshua Bengio -
2020 Poster: Learning to Combine Top-Down and Bottom-Up Signals in Recurrent Neural Networks with Attention over Modules »
Sarthak Mittal · Alex Lamb · Anirudh Goyal · Vikram Voleti · Murray Shanahan · Guillaume Lajoie · Michael Mozer · Yoshua Bengio -
2020 Poster: Online Learned Continual Compression with Adaptive Quantization Modules »
Lucas Caccia · Eugene Belilovsky · Massimo Caccia · Joelle Pineau -
2020 Poster: Constrained Markov Decision Processes via Backward Value Functions »
Harsh Satija · Philip Amortila · Joelle Pineau -
2020 Poster: Interference and Generalization in Temporal Difference Learning »
Emmanuel Bengio · Joelle Pineau · Doina Precup -
2020 Poster: Small-GAN: Speeding up GAN Training using Core-Sets »
Samrath Sinha · Han Zhang · Anirudh Goyal · Yoshua Bengio · Hugo Larochelle · Augustus Odena -
2020 Poster: Invariant Causal Prediction for Block MDPs »
Amy Zhang · Clare Lyle · Shagun Sodhani · Angelos Filos · Marta Kwiatkowska · Joelle Pineau · Yarin Gal · Doina Precup -
2020 Affinity Workshop: New In ML »
Zhen Xu · Sparkle Russell-Puleri · Zhengying Liu · Sinead A Williamson · Matthias W Seeger · Wei-Wei Tu · Samy Bengio · Isabelle Guyon -
2019 Workshop: Identifying and Understanding Deep Learning Phenomena »
Hanie Sedghi · Samy Bengio · Kenji Hata · Aleksander Madry · Ari Morcos · Behnam Neyshabur · Maithra Raghu · Ali Rahimi · Ludwig Schmidt · Ying Xiao -
2019 : Poster discussion »
Roman Novak · Maxime Gabella · Frederic Dreyer · Siavash Golkar · Anh Tong · Irina Higgins · Mirco Milletari · Joe Antognini · Sebastian Goldt · Adín Ramírez Rivera · Roberto Bondesan · Ryo Karakida · Remi Tachet des Combes · Michael Mahoney · Nicholas Walker · Stanislav Fort · Samuel Smith · Rohan Ghosh · Aristide Baratin · Diego Granziol · Stephen Roberts · Dmitry Vetrov · Andrew Wilson · César Laurent · Valentin Thomas · Simon Lacoste-Julien · Dar Gilboa · Daniel Soudry · Anupam Gupta · Anirudh Goyal · Yoshua Bengio · Erich Elsen · Soham De · Stanislaw Jastrzebski · Charles H Martin · Samira Shabanian · Aaron Courville · Shorato Akaho · Lenka Zdeborova · Ethan Dyer · Maurice Weiler · Pim de Haan · Taco Cohen · Max Welling · Ping Luo · zhanglin peng · Nasim Rahaman · Loic Matthey · Danilo J. Rezende · Jaesik Choi · Kyle Cranmer · Lechao Xiao · Jaehoon Lee · Yasaman Bahri · Jeffrey Pennington · Greg Yang · Jiri Hron · Jascha Sohl-Dickstein · Guy Gur-Ari -
2019 : Networking Lunch (provided) + Poster Session »
Abraham Stanway · Alex Robson · Aneesh Rangnekar · Ashesh Chattopadhyay · Ashley Pilipiszyn · Benjamin LeRoy · Bolong Cheng · Ce Zhang · Chaopeng Shen · Christian Schroeder · Christian Clough · Clement DUHART · Clement Fung · Cozmin Ududec · Dali Wang · David Dao · di wu · Dimitrios Giannakis · Dino Sejdinovic · Doina Precup · Duncan Watson-Parris · Gege Wen · George Chen · Gopal Erinjippurath · Haifeng Li · Han Zou · Herke van Hoof · Hillary A Scannell · Hiroshi Mamitsuka · Hongbao Zhang · Jaegul Choo · James Wang · James Requeima · Jessica Hwang · Jinfan Xu · Johan Mathe · Jonathan Binas · Joonseok Lee · Kalai Ramea · Kate Duffy · Kevin McCloskey · Kris Sankaran · Lester Mackey · Letif Mones · Loubna Benabbou · Lynn Kaack · Matthew Hoffman · Mayur Mudigonda · Mehrdad Mahdavi · Michael McCourt · Mingchao Jiang · Mohammad Mahdi Kamani · Neel Guha · Niccolo Dalmasso · Nick Pawlowski · Nikola Milojevic-Dupont · Paulo Orenstein · Pedram Hassanzadeh · Pekka Marttinen · Ramesh Nair · Sadegh Farhang · Samuel Kaski · Sandeep Manjanna · Sasha Luccioni · Shuby Deshpande · Soo Kim · Soukayna Mouatadid · Sunghyun Park · Tao Lin · Telmo Felgueira · Thomas Hornigold · Tianle Yuan · Tom Beucler · Tracy Cui · Volodymyr Kuleshov · Wei Yu · yang song · Ydo Wexler · Yoshua Bengio · Zhecheng Wang · Zhuangfang Yi · Zouheir Malki -
2019 Workshop: Generative Modeling and Model-Based Reasoning for Robotics and AI »
Aravind Rajeswaran · Emanuel Todorov · Igor Mordatch · William Agnew · Amy Zhang · Joelle Pineau · Michael Chang · Dumitru Erhan · Sergey Levine · Kimberly Stachenfeld · Marvin Zhang -
2019 Poster: State-Reification Networks: Improving Generalization by Modeling the Distribution of Hidden Representations »
Alex Lamb · Jonathan Binas · Anirudh Goyal · Sandeep Subramanian · Ioannis Mitliagkas · Yoshua Bengio · Michael Mozer -
2019 Poster: On the Spectral Bias of Neural Networks »
Nasim Rahaman · Aristide Baratin · Devansh Arpit · Felix Draxler · Min Lin · Fred Hamprecht · Yoshua Bengio · Aaron Courville -
2019 Oral: On the Spectral Bias of Neural Networks »
Nasim Rahaman · Aristide Baratin · Devansh Arpit · Felix Draxler · Min Lin · Fred Hamprecht · Yoshua Bengio · Aaron Courville -
2019 Oral: State-Reification Networks: Improving Generalization by Modeling the Distribution of Hidden Representations »
Alex Lamb · Jonathan Binas · Anirudh Goyal · Sandeep Subramanian · Ioannis Mitliagkas · Yoshua Bengio · Michael Mozer -
2019 Poster: Area Attention »
Yang Li · Lukasz Kaiser · Samy Bengio · Si Si -
2019 Poster: Manifold Mixup: Better Representations by Interpolating Hidden States »
Vikas Verma · Alex Lamb · Christopher Beckham · Amir Najafi · Ioannis Mitliagkas · David Lopez-Paz · Yoshua Bengio -
2019 Poster: GMNN: Graph Markov Neural Networks »
Meng Qu · Yoshua Bengio · Jian Tang -
2019 Poster: Separable value functions across time-scales »
Joshua Romoff · Peter Henderson · Ahmed Touati · Yann Ollivier · Joelle Pineau · Emma Brunskill -
2019 Oral: Area Attention »
Yang Li · Lukasz Kaiser · Samy Bengio · Si Si -
2019 Oral: Separable value functions across time-scales »
Joshua Romoff · Peter Henderson · Ahmed Touati · Yann Ollivier · Joelle Pineau · Emma Brunskill -
2019 Oral: GMNN: Graph Markov Neural Networks »
Meng Qu · Yoshua Bengio · Jian Tang -
2019 Oral: Manifold Mixup: Better Representations by Interpolating Hidden States »
Vikas Verma · Alex Lamb · Christopher Beckham · Amir Najafi · Ioannis Mitliagkas · David Lopez-Paz · Yoshua Bengio -
2018 Poster: Mutual Information Neural Estimation »
Mohamed Belghazi · Aristide Baratin · Sai Rajeswar · Sherjil Ozair · Yoshua Bengio · R Devon Hjelm · Aaron Courville -
2018 Oral: Mutual Information Neural Estimation »
Mohamed Belghazi · Aristide Baratin · Sai Rajeswar · Sherjil Ozair · Yoshua Bengio · R Devon Hjelm · Aaron Courville -
2018 Poster: Focused Hierarchical RNNs for Conditional Sequence Processing »
Rosemary Nan Ke · Konrad Zolna · Alessandro Sordoni · Zhouhan Lin · Adam Trischler · Yoshua Bengio · Joelle Pineau · Laurent Charlin · Christopher Pal -
2018 Poster: Fast Decoding in Sequence Models Using Discrete Latent Variables »
Lukasz Kaiser · Samy Bengio · Aurko Roy · Ashish Vaswani · Niki Parmar · Jakob Uszkoreit · Noam Shazeer -
2018 Oral: Fast Decoding in Sequence Models Using Discrete Latent Variables »
Lukasz Kaiser · Samy Bengio · Aurko Roy · Ashish Vaswani · Niki Parmar · Jakob Uszkoreit · Noam Shazeer -
2018 Oral: Focused Hierarchical RNNs for Conditional Sequence Processing »
Rosemary Nan Ke · Konrad Zolna · Alessandro Sordoni · Zhouhan Lin · Adam Trischler · Yoshua Bengio · Joelle Pineau · Laurent Charlin · Christopher Pal -
2018 Poster: An Inference-Based Policy Gradient Method for Learning Options »
Matthew Smith · Herke van Hoof · Joelle Pineau -
2018 Oral: An Inference-Based Policy Gradient Method for Learning Options »
Matthew Smith · Herke van Hoof · Joelle Pineau -
2017 : Lifelong Learning - Panel Discussion »
Sergey Levine · Joelle Pineau · Balaraman Ravindran · Andrei A Rusu -
2017 : Joelle Pineau: A few modest insights from my lifelong learning »
Joelle Pineau -
2017 Poster: Device Placement Optimization with Reinforcement Learning »
Azalia Mirhoseini · Hieu Pham · Quoc Le · benoit steiner · Mohammad Norouzi · Rasmus Larsen · Yuefeng Zhou · Naveen Kumar · Samy Bengio · Jeff Dean -
2017 Talk: Device Placement Optimization with Reinforcement Learning »
Azalia Mirhoseini · Hieu Pham · Quoc Le · benoit steiner · Mohammad Norouzi · Rasmus Larsen · Yuefeng Zhou · Naveen Kumar · Samy Bengio · Jeff Dean -
2017 Poster: Sharp Minima Can Generalize For Deep Nets »
Laurent Dinh · Razvan Pascanu · Samy Bengio · Yoshua Bengio -
2017 Poster: A Closer Look at Memorization in Deep Networks »
David Krueger · Yoshua Bengio · Stanislaw Jastrzebski · Maxinder S. Kanwal · Nicolas Ballas · Asja Fischer · Emmanuel Bengio · Devansh Arpit · Tegan Maharaj · Aaron Courville · Simon Lacoste-Julien -
2017 Talk: A Closer Look at Memorization in Deep Networks »
David Krueger · Yoshua Bengio · Stanislaw Jastrzebski · Maxinder S. Kanwal · Nicolas Ballas · Asja Fischer · Emmanuel Bengio · Devansh Arpit · Tegan Maharaj · Aaron Courville · Simon Lacoste-Julien -
2017 Talk: Sharp Minima Can Generalize For Deep Nets »
Laurent Dinh · Razvan Pascanu · Samy Bengio · Yoshua Bengio